Posted: May 07, 2024
| Player of the Year | Camila Zepeda - PCC | |
| Pitcher of the Year | Jolissa Valdez - EAC | |
| Coach of the Year | Alexis Aguirre - EAC |
| ACCAC First Team | ||
| Battery | EAC | Jolissa Valdez |
| Battery | PC | Sydney Haake |
| Battery | PCC | Jazmyne Waddell |
| Battery | AWC | Jessie Garcia |
| Infield | PCC | Camila Zepeda |
| Infield | EAC | Trinity Moreno |
| Infield | YC | Torie Au |
| Infield | PC | Danitza Hernandez |
| Outfield | SMCC | Dionna Leanio |
| Outfield | AWC | Kaity McLaughlin |
| Outfield | CAC | Alivia De la Cruz |
| Utility | EAC | Braelynn Kaulu ChoyFoo |
| ACCAC Second Team | ||
| Battery | YC | Samara Romero |
| Battery | PC | Katie Hofmann |
| Battery | PCC | Alexis Tsosie-Hood |
| Battery | EAC | Illeana Cosillos |
| Infield | SMCC | Iliana Munoz |
| Infield | CGCC | Jolee Benson |
| Infield | AWC | Valerie Joaquin |
| Infield | CAC | Lauren Newlin |
| Outfield | PCC | Talia Martin |
| Outfield | PCC | Aubrey Marx |
| Outfield | SCC | Sydnee Levandowski |
| Utility | SMCC | Taylor Christensen |
| ACCAC Third Team | ||
| Battery | PC | Alyssa Tinnin |
| Battery | PCC | Mallory Zylinski-Wrobel |
| Infield | PC | Riley Martens |
| Infield | EAC | Gianna Villegas |
| Infield | EAC | Ocearn Mathews |
| Outfield | AWC | Jayleen Espinoza |
| Outfield | EAC | Alex Genty |
| Utility | AWC | Mollie Forbes |
| Utility | PC | Asia Jones |
| Division I All-Region | ||
| Battery | EAC | Jolissa Valdez |
| Battery | PCC | Jazmyne Waddell |
| Battery | AWC | Jessie Garcia |
| Battery | YC | Samara Romero |
| Battery | PCC | Alexis Tsosie-Hood |
| Infield | PCC | Camila Zepeda |
| Infield | EAC | Trinity Moreno |
| Infield | YC | Torie Au |
| Infield | AWC | Valerie Joaquin |
| Infield | CAC | Lauren Newlin |
| Outfield | AWC | Kaity McLaughlin |
| Outfield | CAC | Alivia De la Cruz |
| Outfield | PCC | Talia Martin |
| Outfield | PCC | Aubrey Marx |
| DP | AWC | Mollie Forbes |
| Utility | EAC | Braelynn Kaulu ChoyFoo |
| Division II All-Region | ||
| Battery | PC | Sydney Haake |
| Battery | PC | Katie Hofmann |
| Battery | PC | Alyssa Tinnin |
| Battery | CGCC | Ahjada Solomon |
| Infield | PC | Danitza Hernandez |
| Infield | SMCC | Iliana Munoz |
| Infield | CGCC | Jolee Benson |
| Infield | PC | Riley Martens |
| Outfield | SMCC | Dionna Leanio |
| Outfield | SCC | Sydnee Levandowski |
| Outfield | GCC | Taylor Caccavale |
| DP | SMCC | Taylor Christensen |
| Utility | PC | Asia Jones |
